If you’re ready to buy an anal Fleshlight, take my advice. Don’t just throw away money on something you’re not going to enjoy using. If you don’t do at least a little bit of research, you could end up with an anal Fleshlight that is so tight that it scrapes and hurts your penis!
If you just select your butt Fleshlight because it carries your favorite porn star’s name, you could be in for a surprise when it doesn’t deliver realistic anal sex or your penis doesn’t get enough stimulation. Therefore, it’s essential to choose wisely and make sure your new anal Fleshlight is suitable for your penis size.
I know what perfect anal is like, so let me try and help you find the right combination of tightness, suction control, stimulation, and texture for the best masturbation sessions of your life.
How to Choose Anal Fleshlight
Whether you’re big, small, or somewhere in between, penis size is one of the most important things to consider when buying a masturbator for anal sex stimulation. Our comparison table is an excellent place to start finding the best anal Fleshlight for you.
For now, we’re focused on anal Fleshlights, so be sure to deselect the other options for oral and vaginal Fleshlights. Then choose your penis size to indicate your tightness preference. This is probably the most critical aspect of choosing the best anal Fleshlight for you and your penis.
My experience is that the texture of your toy contributes significantly to your masturbation experience. Tightness is one thing, but Fleshlight sleeve texture is what creates the intensity after your penis enters the orifice itself. Therefore, you need to find a texture that is interesting and stimulating.
Any time you’re looking for a realistic anal sex experience that takes it to the next level, think with your penis. Will those ribs be too intense and stimulating for me and cause premature ejaculation? Famous female porn stars often inspire sex toys.
There is even a selection of anal Fleshlight sleeves inspired by male porn stars if that is your preference.
If a realistic anal sex experience is your goal, don’t just think about how much you like someone’s butt on screen. Instead, focus on our comparison table to determine if a particular texture is right for you.
If the penetration score is low, maybe the orifice lacks tightness. On the other hand, if the tightness is off the charts and you’re swinging 10 inches and have a considerable girth, you might need to look elsewhere.
Defining the importance of features like realism, tightness, variation, smoothness, intensity, and ease of cleanup, you can find your best anal fleshlight.
Each toy is unique so that you can evaluate it based on its design.
For instance, the Next Level texture inspired by Adriana Chechik is one of my favorite anal fleshlight because of suction, intensity, and tightness. The texture pattern will have intensity regardless of how far your penis is pushing inside of it. But if you’re over 8 inches, it’s not going to all fit.
10 Best Anal Fleshlight Reviews
Spice Eva Lovia
When it comes to finding the best anal Fleshlight, anything with Eva Lovia’s name on it is probably a good place to start. This model features a very tight orifice and extensive ribbing right at the entrance for a next-level entry experience.
Once I pushed deeper, it was pretty tight, but that is normal for anal sex. No wonder that this sleeve is extremely realistic.
Eva has come a long way since her debut in lesbian-only scenes, so I am very happy to explore her tight sex toy. This Fleshlight sleeve is also a good fit for guys without a huge penis. And, even if you are on the bigger side, it is still an enjoyable Fleshlight sleeve.
Shameless Brandi Love
Brandi Love is a niche porn star. She is a little bit older than most of the other Fleshlight girls in porn, but there is something for everyone in the world of anal Fleshlights.
One thing that sets Ms. Love apart from many of her contemporaries is that she claims to be an anal virgin. So it should be no surprise that her butt Fleshlight is very tight.
I agree with many other Reddit reviewers that its overall effect is very satisfying. Even smaller-sized users should be able to enjoy the intensity and tightness.
Brandi is also a talented and accomplished writer and speaker. So, after you are finished cleaning up her Fleshlight sleeve, you can read her book “Getting Wild Sex from Your Conservative Woman.”
Next Level Adriana Chechik
Adriana Checkik is an all-natural porn star with a seemingly insatiable appetite for sex. She is definitely a sexual dynamo, and that intensity is reflected in her Next Level butt Fleshlight.
Take it from me. This toy’s texture will take your anal sex stimulation to the Next Level.
A variety of ribs, spiraled chambers, and a tight little orifice is guaranteed to help you get a higher intensity masturbation experience.
This Fleshlight girl is so tight. It tends to make a lot of noise. While noisy anal sex might be pretty realistic, this toy might be too intense to claim to be a realistic anal sex experience.
It is intense at all depths, so it is perfect for a smaller guy.
Texas Tornado Alexis Texas
Alexis Texas is a southern belle with a famous butt that has starred in dozens of adult films, many featuring anal sex. So no one should be surprised that her anal Fleshlight is a bit of a wild ride.
It’s called a Texas Tornado for a reason, featuring an intense five chambers with repeating twisted textures that don’t leave a penis anywhere to hide. Each thrust sends your penis into a bit of a frenzy with a realistic descent into a textured pattern.
Despite the aggressive texturing, it is not so intense that it drives you right over the edge. Instead, it draws you in and lets you explore its depths. The lack of tightness makes it perfect for a man with a lot of size.
The repeating nature of the texture design makes it a bit predictable and easy to pace yourself, so IMHO this sleeve is one of the best when it comes to realistic anal sex with a male masturbator.
To sum it up, I didn’t feel like my penis was being strangled, but there was continuous spiral stimulation that felt realistic.
Karma Lana Rhoades
Lana Rhoades was raised in a very religious household in a quiet small town in Illinois. But if you’re a fan of her porn career, you know that she is one of the best when it comes to generating lust.
Her Karma anal Fleshlight allows the user to tweak their own experience a bit with an adjustable end cap, tailoring the suction effects to your needs.
When you first enter the toy at its loosest setting, there is a decent amount of suction, but if you want more, just tighten the cap. This design isn’t unique to this toy, but it combines well with the texture pattern to create a complete experience that isn’t off the tightness chart.
A side view of the Karma shows that there is a general narrowing of the sleeve after about three and a half inches of penetration. The three rings get gradually tighter, then a bumpy chamber that gets very tight. And if you push past six or so inches, that same texture is repeated, giving a nice grip when you go deep.
The Mini-Lotus Fleshlight’s texture is designed to appeal to all men. Almost immediately after pushing into the customizable orifice, your penis will be rewarded with a tight, small chamber.
After that, you can find your way through a variety of other chambers designed to deliver an enhanced Lotus experience.
Many reviews of the original Lotus lamented the fact that you need to be pretty long in the penis department to really enjoy all of its texture.
This new and improved design brings all of its rewarding textures closer to the entry point, making it more accessible for those who might be less endowed. If you can push past the lotus node, there are still five more ringer chambers to enjoy with this anal Fleshlight texture.
As much fun as this toy is, the cleaning process tends to be a bit of a pain, as there are many chambers to clean.
Siren Anikka Albrite
The Siren anal Fleshlight is remarkably intense and tight, with strong stimulation and suction. But it is so intense; it is not as realistic as some other Fleshlight sleeves. If your desire is a texture that offers a realistic anal sex experience, this might not be your best choice.
But, if you’re planning on watching one of Annika’s famously adventurous anal sex scenes while you use it, this toy can be equally thrilling. If you are looking for something tight and very stimulating, this is one of the best anal Fleshlights.
My Tips for Your First Anal Fleshlight Experience
Warm It Up
For a realistic experience, regardless of the texture you choose, be sure to warm up your Fleshlight. You don’t want your first time to go wrong and feel cold and unrealistic.
You may want to invest in a Fleshlight warming sleeve to make your masturbation experience feel more like penetrating soft, real skin.
Once you’re inside of a Fleshlight sleeve, it should also feel warm and inviting, just like a real butt. So make sure to take some advice and understand the best options for warming up your Fleshlight to make the experience as natural as possible.
Get Lubed Up
All of the butt Fleshlight models I reviewed are pretty damn tight. Even models that are supposed to be usable with 9 inches or more of penis are not lacking for tightness. So, be sure to be prepared with a lot of water-based lubricants to avoid chafing, injury, and damage to your toy.
Remember, most other types of lubricants can damage the Superskin material of your anal Fleshlight, so they should not be used.
Adjust the Suction
Many of the best and most realistic anal Fleshlight models feature an adjustable end cap. Twisting this cap on tighter or making it looser can offer a different level of suction effect, helping you fine-tune the experience to make it feel more like realistic anal sex.
Don’t be shy. Play around with the Fleshlight sleeve to get the right level of stimulation and realism for your masturbation session.
In my experience, cleaning a Fleshlight can be a bit difficult, especially when it’s a very intense stimulation experience that makes a big mess. Also, it can be a bit of a bummer to have to collect yourself and start a lengthy cleanup process after a satisfying orgasm.
But, here are a couple of the easiest models to clean.
This dual orifice Fleshlight is open-ended, meaning it does not have an end cap. Take it from either end.
It is also less than half the size of the original Fleshlight, so you can push right through it and deposit your end results outside of the chamber while it’s still around the base of your penis. Just rinse with warm water and allow it to air dry.
Blue Ice Fleshskins
This model of Fleshlight is only a sleeve, so it doesn’t have a case. As a result, it doesn’t have much suction, and you or your partner control the intensity of the grip by hand. But what it lacks in suction and intensity, it makes up for with simple and easy cleanup.
If you are curious about what goes into cleaning a Fleshlight or anal Fleshlight, check out this guide.